Their words. Not ours.We’ve just put them in order.

One house, three doors

Three doors. One house.

Two records, kept side by side, and one voice that asks the question. Come in through any door; all three lead to the same place.

How the three work together: the Crown's record and the citizen's record, set side by side, meet in the voice that asks the question.the record, verifiedthe receipts, in their wordsset side by side: the gap showsThe Second Readingthe two records, side by side03Signals Not SilenceThe voice01Second ChambersThe Crown's record02Evidence ChambersThe citizen's record
  1. 01You are here

    Second Chambers

    The Crown's record

    What institutions said, wrote, funded and are running, read at the source, dated and graded line by line.

    You are here
  2. 02

    Evidence Chambers

    The citizen's record

    What happened to people inside the system, in their own exact words and dated. Private, and kept by the person.

    Enter Evidence Chambers
  3. 03

    Signals Not Silence

    The voice

    Where the two records meet. The question is put to the office, the clock starts, and the people sign.

    Enter Signals Not Silence
  1. 01Read the recordSecond Chambers
  2. 02Keep your ownEvidence Chambers
  3. 03Ask the questionSignals Not Silence
  4. 04Pass it onThe Inheritance
What it pulls

Ten findings. Every one from the record.

Each one is a kind of holding the software pulls, shown as the finding it produced: the document, their words, the record, the count, and the question. Nothing here is a claim.

  1. 01The measure150
  2. 02The door66
  3. 03The law219
  4. 04The money134
  5. 05The reaction2,117
  6. 06The silence577
  7. 07The lobby13
  8. 08The words167
  9. 09The warnings414
  10. 10The inquiries65
01

The measure

The checks removed from the law: a report, a review, a publication, an independence, a consultation, a target.

150checks removed from the law
01

The document

Reserve Bank of New Zealand (Economic Objective) Amendment Act 2023, s 4 · in force 20 December 2023 · held: legislation.govt.nz

02

Their words

“Replace section 9(1)(a) and the heading above section 9(1)(a) with: Economic objective (a) the economic objective of achieving and maintaining stability in the general level of prices over the medium term; and”

— Reserve Bank of New Zealand (Economic Objective) Amendment Act 2023, s 4legislation.govt.nz, the Act as served · grade V
03

The record

150 checks removed from the law · 36 reporting · 18 review · 18 publication · 16 independence · 16 consultation · 15 objective or target

04

Side by side

118 less safe · 32 safer or no direction · 79%

the register's own reading: the signal on each row

05

The count

150 checks removed from the law · where it is counted: The checks removed, each with its Act, its provision and the words that removed it · grade V

06

Say it

Listed, a removed check is still a count.

07

The question

Not yet asked

02

The door

Who was appointed to hold it.

66rows in the appointments register
01

The document

The appointments register · 66 rows, 24 Nov 2023 to 18 Nov 2025 (assent) · 60 sources held

02

Their words

“A Treaty Principles Bill will be introduced and supported to a select committee for the public to have their say.”

— The Governor-General, Dame Cindy Kiro, for the Government (Speech from the Throne)The Speech from the Throne repeats the Tribunal clause · grade V
03

The record

66 rows in the appointments register · 60 sources held

04

Side by side

141The Tribunal seat · days from Prebble’s warrant, 10 Oct 2024, to his notice of resignation, 28 Feb 2025

13The Board’s interviews · candidates, before a panel of three: the Ministry, BusinessNZ and the New Zealand Initiative

6Appointed · members of the Board, on the Minister’s recommendation, s 38(1)

$1,265The chair’s fee · a day; a member’s, $800

05

The count

66 rows in the appointments register · where it is counted: The appointments register, each row to its gazette notice or document · grade V

06

Say it

Named and dated, an appointment is a row.

07

The question

Not yet asked

03

The law

The Acts and the instruments made, and how many under urgency.

219Acts on the law map
01

The document

The law map, 241 nodes and 300 joins · the regulations register, 1,040 instruments, 2023-11-27 to 2026-08-22 · read at legislation.govt.nz

02

Their words

Not held

03

The record

219 Acts on the map · 152 passed under urgency · 1,040 instruments in the register, 2023-11-27 to 2026-08-22

04

Side by side

152 passed under urgency · 67 not under urgency · 69%

05

The count

219 Acts on the law map · where it is counted: The law map and the regulations register, every Act and instrument read at legislation.govt.nz · grade V

06

Say it

Mapped, a law change is a row with a date.

07

The question

Not yet asked

04

The money

The donations the Commission publishes, over $20,000 and $30,000.

134donations over $20,000 declared
01

The document

The Electoral Commission’s own tables of donations over $20,000 and $30,000 · read 2026-10-03

02

Their words

Not held

03

The record

134 donations over $20,000 since the coalition agreements, 24 November 2023 · $7,280,942 in all, our sum of the Commission's figures

04

Side by side

$7,280,942Our sum of their figures, computed at build

24in the fullest month, 2026-07

05

The count

134 donations over $20,000 declared since the coalition agreements, 24 November 2023 · where it is counted: The Electoral Commission's own tables, read 2026-10-03 · grade V

06

Say it

Counted, the money is a table.

07

The question

Not yet asked

05

The reaction

What the bait gets back. Every reply becomes the proof the story was true.

2,117uses read as React or the concern
01

The document

The House, 2003 to 2026, every sitting day the library holds · Hansard as served

02

Their words

Not held

03

The record

2,117 of 3,956 uses read as React or the concern · 1,032 as the bait or the flip

04

Side by side

Not held

05

The count

2,117 uses read as React or the concern · where it is counted: The House, 2003 to 2026, every sitting day the library holds, placed on the wheel by a reader who never saw who spoke · a draft reading · grade a reading

06

Say it

Without the reaction, it cannot run.

07

The question

Not yet asked

06

The silence

The questions put to an office, and the days without an answer.

577days without an answer
01

The document

The Question Bank · 24 cards, each a row · the clock counted live

02

Their words

“regular, publicly reported data about bullying in schools”, and said: “I look forward to discussing this with the Ministry of Education.”

— On 17 March 2025 the Chief Children’s Commissioner, Dr Claire Achmad, called publicly forthe Question Bank, the card's record · grade V
03

The record

24 questions in the bank · 8 answered · 1 waiting (577 days, the longest) · 15 drafted

04

Side by side

8 answered · 16 waiting or drafted · 33%

05

The count

577 days without an answer · where it is counted: The Question Bank: every card a row, the clock counted live · grade V

06

Say it

Asked and clocked, silence is counted.

07

The question

Will the Ministry of Education introduce a national count of bullying in schools, and if not, why not? — Put to an office · sent 17 March 2025 · 577 days without an answer

07

The lobby

The groups that argue for a result, in their own words.

13groups held, in their own words
01

The document

The pressure groups register · 13 groups, 64 sources held, every quotation keyed to one

02

Their words

“We are a pressure group not just a traditional ‘think tank’ or business association.”

— Taxpayers’ UnionTaxpayers’ Union, “Our mission” (its own page, undated) · grade V
03

The record

13 groups held, in their own words · 7 network · 6 counterpart

04

Side by side

6people the register holds in two or more places: Taxpayers’ Union, Hobson’s Pledge, Free Speech Union, Atlas Network, Curia, in the Union’s own poll release, The New Zealand Initiative

Jordan Williams · The Taxpayers’ Union and the Free Speech Union; an Atlas Smith Fellow

David Farrar · The Taxpayers’ Union and Curia Market Research

Michael Johnston · The New Zealand Initiative and the Crown’s curriculum advisory group

Don Brash · Hobson’s Pledge; a named backer of the Free Speech Coalition

05

The count

13 groups held, in their own words · where it is counted: The pressure groups register: every quotation keyed to a held source, checked at build · grade V

06

Say it

Read the same way, the lobby is a list.

07

The question

Not yet asked

08

The words

The story told first: what was said about a group, before the facts.

167verified rows
01

The document

The Crown on race ledger · 1,114 rows, 1839 to today, each to a held source

02

Their words

2024-04-11Ministry of Justice"over representation".

2024-05-01Oranga Tamariki officials (RIS advising agency; MoJ paras 135–187)"Racial profiling and bias … may become more significant".

2024-05-10Waitangi Tribunal"clear breaches"; "rushed and arbitrary" (no race word).

2024-05-17Waitangi Tribunal (Judge Sarah Reeves presiding)"inequitable and discriminatory"; "discriminatory and racist rhetoric against Māori" (the rhetoric the policy would enable — not the Crown's own words).

The State’s own offices, in their own words · grade V

03

The record

167 verified rows since the coalition agreements, 24 November 2023 · 1,114 rows in the ledger, 1839 to today

04

Side by side

Not held

05

The count

167 verified rows since the coalition agreements, 24 November 2023 · where it is counted: The Crown on race ledger, every row to a held source · ✅ and V · grade V

06

Say it

Kept and dated, the words have nothing to run on.

07

The question

Not yet asked

09

The warnings

What the United Nations' treaty bodies told New Zealand about its children, in their own paragraphs.

414paragraphs from 56 UN documents, 1997 to 2025
01

The document

The UN warnings register · 56 documents held, every paragraph to its page

02

Their words

“In the light of its general comment No. 13 (2011) on the right of the child to freedom from all forms of violence, and taking note of target 16.2 of the Sustainable Development Goals on ending abuse, exploitation, trafficking and all forms of violence against and torture of children, and recalling its previous recommendation (CRC/C/NZL/CO/3-4, para. 35), the Committee urges the State party: (a) To take measures promptly to eradicate the use of violence and abuse of children in State care, including in the form of restraints and detention, and ensure that all professionals and staff working with and for children are provided with the necessary training and supervision and are subjected to the necessary background checks; (b) To investigate promptly incidents of violence and abuse of children in State care, prosecute suspects and duly sanction perpetrators and ensure that child victims have access to child-friendly reporting channels, physical and psychological rehabilitation and health services, including mental health services; (c) To develop a comprehensive strategy to combat abuse and neglect encompassing all children in all settings, with particular attention to Maori and Pasifika children and children with disabilities; (d) To establish a national database on all cases of violence against children in families, schools and institutional care and undertake a comprehensive assessment of the extent, causes and nature of such violence; (e) To regularly monitor and analyse the effectiveness of the Vulnerable Children's Plan, the Violence Intervention Programme and the National Child Protection Alert System and other policies and programmes against child abuse and neglect; (f) To allocate sufficient human, technical and financial resources to Children's Teams and other front-line services to adequately respond to reported cases of child abuse; (g) To further strengthen awareness-raising and education programmes, including campaigns, to prevent and combat child abuse, with the involvement of children, with particular attention to Maori and Pasifika children and children with disabilities.…”

— Committee on the Rights of the Child · CRC, CRC/C/NZL/CO/5 ¶2330 September 2016 · on the Committee’s urgent list (¶4) · grade V
03

The record

414 paragraphs · 24 on a committee’s urgent list · 120 CRC · 99 CERD · 86 CAT (and OPCAT) · 57 CRPD · 52 CESCR

04

Side by side

24 marked urgent by the committee · 390 not marked urgent · 6%

05

The count

414 paragraphs from 56 UN documents, 1997 to 2025 · where it is counted: The UN warnings register, every paragraph pulled verbatim from the held document · grade V

06

Say it

Kept and counted, a warning is a dated paragraph.

07

The question

Not yet asked

10

The inquiries

What each inquiry recommended, what was said, what was done, and what it cost.

65inquiries on the tracker, 1858 to 2026
01

The document

The inquiries tracker · 29 with their documents held, 89 documents, 8,499 pages

02

Their words

“Society’s discriminatory attitudes towards difference, including racism, ableism, disablism, sexism, homophobia, transphobia, punitive attitudes towards whānau and individuals who need support, all had one thing in common: they devalued and dehumanised children, young people and adults in care. This made it more likely for people in care to be abused and neglected and for that treatment to be justified by abusers, bystanders and leaders of institutions. It also made it all too easy for people in care to be ignored and forgotten by the rest of Aotearoa New Zealand.”

— Royal Commission of Inquiry into Abuse in Care, Whanaketia, Executive summary, para 24tabled 24 July 2024 · printed p 34 · grade V
03

The record

65 inquiries · 1,492 recommendations counted · 8 Health · 2 School · 32 State Care · 9 Family Violence & Sexual Assault · 6 Justice, Policing & Disability · 5 Welfare & Poverty · 3 Te Tiriti · Waitangi Tribunal

04

Side by side

2 with a cost on the record · 63 cost not held · 3%

05

The count

65 inquiries on the tracker, 1858 to 2026 · where it is counted: The inquiries tracker, each inquiry to its report · grade V

06

Say it

Tracked, an inquiry is a count of what was done.

07

The question

Not yet asked

The live window

Watch the record go in, and the file come out.

Every source flows into one sheet. Every line is graded before anyone may cite it. Keep scrolling: the window turns its own pages, and every row is real.

HansardNew Zealand Gazettelegislation.govt.nzRoyal Commission of InquiryThe TreasuryStats NZParliament TVThe bank243,279rows on one sheet · every line graded before it is cited
THE QUESTION BANKlive · a real sheet
The question, in one linePut toStatusGrade
“Back to the original intent.” Which words of the 1975 Act state another intent?Minister for Māori Developmentdrafted(owed)
“Wound up for their own good.” Will the Tribunal exist on the last day of this Parliament?Deputy Prime MinisterdraftedV
What has the Minister done to keep children safe?Minister for Childrendrafted(owed)
Will the Ministry count bullying?Minister of Educationwaiting(owed)
Emergency housing use fell 81% in a year. Where did the people go?Minister for Social Development and Employmentanswered(owed)
The law sets child poverty targets. Are they being met?Minister for Child Poverty Reductionanswered(owed)
THE 4D AUDITlive · a real sheet
The cardBaySignalGrade
The Children and Young People’s Commission (board), 2023–2025OUTSafety removedV
Kia Manawanui (2021)1D SAIDSafety removedV
Oranga Hinengaro (2023)1D SAIDSafety removedV2
Fair Pay AgreementsOUTSafety removedV
The Clean Car DiscountOUTSafety removedV
Smokefree generation measuresOUTSafety removedV
The Askone question, as the bank holds it

Emergency housing use fell 81% in a year. Where did the people go?

Put to
Minister for Social Development and Employment
Status
answered
Grade
(owed)

The answer. Minister Tama Potaka, January 2025: “Emergency housing will always be available as a last resort for those who need it.” Minister Louise Upston stands by the decision to tighten the criteria (verbatim to add). The Ministry’s chief executive defended the staff metrics (verbatim to add).

The Case File92 entries, 2001 to 2026
  1. 2001
    The stated political awakening, in his words

    “It was sitting at assembly in sixth form and watching the principal of my school [Auckland Grammar] get into a huge and public fight with the then-Minister of Education T…”

  2. 2005
    The earliest published words in any holding: “The Welfare State We’re In”

    “It was only a matter of time before the welfare issue would go large.…”

  3. 2005
    Branch President, ACT on Campus, University of Auckland

    “…”

Open the whole file

By the numbers

Chamber One, measured

Every figure read from the live site's own module. Nothing typed. Follow the money

243,279
rows on one sheet · The Evidence Bank
VMeasured September 2026
55,406
curated line by line · Ruled on by a human
VMeasured September 2026
187,873
banked in bulk · Queued and graded
VMeasured September 2026
1,083
films verified · Against the platform’s own record
VMeasured September 2026
Two names, one house

Second Chambers reads the public record back to the public, in any country.

Every promise, statute, budget line, parliamentary speech, inquiry finding and film, in the speakers’ own words, dated, with the source on every line and a grade on every fact.

The software

Second Chambers

It reads every document, grades every line and hands the file over, finished. Simple to use. Built for any country that brings its own record.

Request a demo
The advocacy and the teeth

Signals Not Silence

The founding chamber, in Aotearoa. It puts the question to the office, starts the clock, and counts the silence.

Read the founding chamber
What it produces

Every kind of holding. In the order the record moves.

Each kind is counted from the file that holds it. Press one to open the example this site shows; the whole holding opens on Signals Not Silence.

54kinds
985,573items

Counted at build, 7 Oct 2026. A count the builder cannot read says so. The record, as held

01

You arrive

Pick your door. One chamber.

2 kinds · 25 items
02

Your record

Your private paper trail. · Submit your receipts. Anonymised.

7 kinds · 473,370 items
03

The two records meet

The Crown's record. The lived record. · Read side by side. · Circles at the round table.

35 kinds · 511,568 items
04

The heavy lifting

The policy, and the People's Impact Statement.

3 kinds · 490 items
05

The people decide

Back to you, as a petition. · The record answers.

7 kinds · 120 items
How it works

We have done the hard work, so you do not have to.

You never see the machine. You set your filters once, by practice, industry, minister, Act or topic. Every night the watchers read the record and a person rules on every arrival. Every morning your desk holds the evidence, bundled and ready.

01Set your filters, once

Your practice, your firm, your industry, your cause. The ministers, the Acts, the amendments and the topics you have to be right about.

02Wake up to the desk

What arrived overnight, each row verified by a person, with the date, the speaker, their words and the grade. Behind it, every past row on the same filters.

03Check it yourself

The document to download, the passage highlighted as printed, the link to the page it was pulled from. Alerts on anything that moves.

The Morning Desk

Your desk, one morning: real rows of the founding chamber, ruled overnight, the highlight and the document on every card.
Instruments

Press one. It reads the sheet.

With a sheet open, press one and a drawer opens at the right with that instrument's output drawn from the sheet's rows.

A part with no column prints Not held: the instrument never guesses.

15 instruments on the rail. Each one is a method the house uses on the record, drawn from whatever sheet is open.

  1. 01
    Question

    The Question Card, six parts: the record · they said · the question · put to · the clock · the answer

  2. 02
    4D tray

    The 4D audit: 1D SAID · 2D WRITTEN · 3D FUNDED · 4D RUNNING, one card a bay

  3. 03
    Finding

    THE FINDING, seven steps in one order: document · their words · record · side by side · count · say it · question

  4. 04
    Stamps

    The two signals: SAFER (green) · LESS SAFE (red), only where a row holds the direction

  5. 05
    Clocks

    How many days each took, and the median; never the adjective

  6. 06
    The gate

    What is not ready to leave: the machine's refusal list; it never clears a row

The whole rail

15 instruments. One rail.

Every method the house uses on the record, as the engine's own rail names it. The six that draw from a sheet open in the window above; press one.

  • Timeline

    Every dated row, oldest first, one aligned column

  • Count

    The totals, added and said: our sum of their figures

  • Claim v record

    Said beside done, every join labelled DOCUMENTED or SIMILARITY

  • The door

    Who holds the door: complained to · receives · investigates · decides · reviews; the same name in two seats, flagged

  • Verbs

    The verb audit: must, shall, may

  • Cite

    One row as a citation: their words, the speaker, the date, the source, the grade

  • Bundle

    Every document on this sheet, in order, numbered, hashed as served; never by a person's name

  • Signal test

    Signal, or noise? Five kinds of noise come out of their words; what is left is the signal; then five questions

  • Non-answer

    The sentence says what was done and not who did it: eight devices lit, and beside each, by whom? what was done?

Every piece

Sixteen features. One bank behind all of them.

Each one is a page of its own, drawn from the same rows under the same grade. Open any of them and the founding chamber's own record is running inside it.

All of the platform
The Case File

The whole file, on one document. Assembled while you sleep.

A person, a subject or your filters in. Overnight, every graded row that touches them is gathered and ordered oldest first: the passage highlighted as printed, linked to the document in the appendix, and the rule that applied set beside each row: the Act and section as enacted, the policy as published. One document, saved to your Google Drive or Dropbox. Handed over, never pleaded.

92 entries, 2001 to 2026 · 12 instruments named

The Case FileWhile You Sleep

Every row shown is a real row of the founding chamber. The Drive and Dropbox routes are built after the gate; the word for any gap between the rule and the record is left to the reader, or to counsel.

The one law

A human rules on every row, and the machine may never cite a row that has not been graded.

Everything on the platform follows from this sentence. No subscriber sees an unruled row. The ask never answers from one. No figure on any page is typed by hand. It is the thing a model cannot fake and a competitor cannot copy.

01Their words, verbatim

Quotations as spoken, with their own punctuation, dated, with the page. No motive language. The reader concludes.

02Four grades, no symbols

V read at source · V2 carried from a named report · S a party's or agency's own text · owed, printed as the word.

03Nothing public without the gate

Eight gates before a page is seen. The machine may refuse; only a person may pass.

04Protected rows never leave

A row naming a private person or a survivor is never exported, never shown, never given to a model.

Who it is for

Three plans. The record itself stays free.

The record is free to the public. Organisations pay to build on it.

  • Governments and policyPut pen to paper on policy from the raw record.
  • Counsel and chambersEvery quote pinned to its page. The record, never advice.
  • Health and careThe inquiry corpus, dated, with the status the state records.
  • NewsroomsTheir words verbatim, at the minute on film, the source a click away.
  • Universities and researchA graded corpus with a stable key on every row.
  • International bodies and NGOsThe same question asked of many countries at once.
  • Regulators and inquiriesWhat was recommended, what was done, and what is not started.
  • free

    The people

    The public record, every register and every meaning are free to everyone, always, and are not a plan.

    Open Chamber One
  • who apply

    Advocates

    An advocate for a good cause who is not one can apply. Ask for the gift, or apply, on the demo page. A registered charity is tested against the charities register. For any other non-profit, and for an advocate who applies, the test is owed.

    Ask for the gift, or apply
  • gifted

    Non-profits

    A non-profit is gifted the licence. The Operator plan for a year, renewed while the cause stands.

    Ask for the gift
  • who pay

    Organisations

    Nothing on this page is an offer. Prices are ruled per organisation and per country.

    • ReaderRead itPrice owed · per seat, per year
    • OperatorBuild on itPrice owed · per organisation, per year
    • ChamberYour countryPrice owed · built to order
    See the plans
The founding chamber

The record, read in moving pictures: their words, the page they are printed on, and nothing added.

Watch a film; its findings stand beside it.

The Films.

Our Readings.

The opener · ACT 01 · Their words, then the record answering. Sets up every film after it.

Next

See the record answer for itself.

A demo begins with your question and the controls, not the features. Ask for a demo, a licence, a chamber, or the gift. Or read the whole ecosystem first: the model, the voice, the teeth, the Open Chamber and the ripple.

  • Non-partisan
  • Independent
  • Evidence-based
Ask for

A demo, a licence, or a chamber.

A live register, drawn

Who gives. To whom. On the record.

Every declared party donation over $20,000 this election year, from the Electoral Commission's own returns, as a graph you can move: the donor as named, the party, the amount, the date, the return itself, and the rule that made it owed.

Open the Donors Graph